Budgeting & Planning

What is zero-based budgeting and when should I use it?

Quick Answer

Zero-based budgeting (ZBB) requires every expense to be justified from scratch each period, starting from a zero base rather than adjusting last year's numbers. Use ZBB when you need to eliminate wasteful spending, during cost transformation programmes, or when entering new markets where historical patterns are irrelevant.

Key Takeaways

  • Every line item starts at zero and must be justified each budget cycle
  • Best suited for cost reduction initiatives or businesses with changing cost structures
  • More time-intensive than incremental budgeting but eliminates legacy waste
  • Can be applied selectively to specific cost categories rather than the entire budget

What is zero-based budgeting?

Zero-based budgeting (ZBB) is a methodology where every expense must be justified for each new budget period. Unlike incremental budgeting, which takes last year's spend as the starting point and adjusts up or down, ZBB starts from zero. Every cost must earn its place.

How ZBB works in practice

1. Define decision units. Break your organisation into decision units β€” typically cost centres or departments. Each unit prepares its own budget from scratch.

2. Build decision packages. For each activity, create a decision package that describes the purpose, cost, benefits, and consequences of not funding it. Rank packages by priority.

3. Evaluate and rank. Leadership reviews all decision packages across the organisation and allocates resources based on strategic priority, not historical precedent.

4. Approve and monitor. Fund the highest-priority packages within your resource envelope. Track spending against approved packages throughout the year.

When to use ZBB

ZBB works best when you suspect significant waste in your cost base, when your business model is changing rapidly, or when entering a new market where historical spending patterns don't apply. It's particularly effective for discretionary spending categories like marketing, travel, and professional services.

When not to use ZBB

ZBB is labour-intensive. For stable cost categories with contractual commitments (rent, core headcount), the effort of justifying from zero every year rarely yields insight. Many companies use a hybrid approach β€” ZBB for discretionary costs, incremental for committed costs.

UK context

Several UK retailers and consumer goods companies adopted ZBB during cost transformation programmes. The approach gained popularity after 3G Capital's high-profile use at AB InBev and Kraft Heinz, though it has since evolved into a more targeted tool rather than a company-wide mandate.

ZBB vs incremental budgeting

The key trade-off is thoroughness versus efficiency. ZBB catches waste that incremental budgeting perpetuates, but it requires significantly more management time. Most growing companies find incremental budgeting with periodic ZBB reviews of specific categories to be the best balance.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

ZBB can work for small businesses, especially startups that need tight cost control. However, the administrative overhead may not be justified. Consider applying ZBB principles to your largest discretionary cost categories rather than every line item.

Most companies that use ZBB do it annually. Some apply it every 2-3 years as a cost reset exercise, using incremental budgeting in between. The right cadence depends on how quickly your cost structure changes.

ZBB is time-consuming, can create anxiety among teams whose budgets are not guaranteed, and may lead to short-term thinking if managers fear losing funding. It also requires strong analytical capabilities and management buy-in.

Yes. Grove FP supports ZBB workflows by letting you build budgets from scratch with templates, track justification notes against each line item, and compare ZBB outputs against prior-year actuals.

Activity-based budgeting (ABB) allocates costs based on activities that drive expenses, using cost drivers and activity volumes. ZBB focuses on justifying every expense from zero. ABB can be used within a ZBB framework to determine the cost of each justified activity.

Put this into practice with Grove FP

Grove FP gives UK finance teams a modern platform for budgeting, forecasting, and reporting β€” so you can focus on the decisions that matter.

Modern FP&A for growing UK businesses

Budgeting, forecasting, and workforce planning in one platform. No credit card required.